Beyond Letter Grades: Measuring Student Mastery
Sep 15, 2026

A student gets an A. Great news, right? But what does that A actually say? Does the child really understand the lesson? Could they use it somewhere new? Or did they just turn in the assignments, study for the test, and check the boxes?
Cameron Smith, co-founder and CEO of Bennett Day School in Chicago, has asked that question since he started the school. He sat down with Mitchell Slater on the School Success Podcast to talk about it, and his take is one every school leader should hear. So let’s dig into what going beyond letter grades and measuring student mastery looks like.
What’s Actually Behind the Grade?
Cameron didn’t sugarcoat it. Schools have spent 100 to 150 years handing students letter grades, and he called that system “really empty of any type of feedback.” Was the student compliant with what the teacher wanted? Did they do extra credit? How did they end up with that grade?
Cameron sees schools as having three main options. There’s traditional letter grading. There’s standards-based grading, where students meet or exceed certain standards. And there’s competency-based grading, where students stay in a feedback loop with their teachers and keep going until they reach depth and mastery in a topic.
Bennett goes with that third option, and once you hear it laid out like that, it just makes sense.
The A in Physics Example
Here’s the one that really sticks. At Bennett, high school students have to show nearly 200 competencies before they get a diploma. One of them is being able to form a hypothesis and then prove or disprove it.
As Cameron put it, that tells you something different than whether a student got an A in physics. An A says the student did well in the class. The competency says they can actually do the thing.
Feedback That Keeps Going
A letter grade is kind of a final word. Competency-based grading flips that around. Teachers give feedback, students work on it, and the cycle keeps going until the student gets there. Feedback tied to a specific competency tells a student where they are, what’s missing, and what to work on next.
And that doesn’t make expectations softer. If anything, they get clearer, because students know exactly what they need to show. It also changes the conversation with families. Instead of “your kid has a B in science,” teachers can talk about the specific skills a student has built and where they still need to grow.
Show It, Don’t Just Test It
So how do you actually see mastery? At Bennett, a lot of it happens through projects.
Cameron shared one from middle school. During a unit on puzzles and games, a group of students who’d just been to an escape room decided to design their own. They used geometry to build an old-school arcade cabinet, programmed their own games, and to get out of the room, you had to beat one of their games.
Nobody needed a worksheet to find out if those children understood angles. The cabinet either fit together or it didn’t.
Bennett also has students share their work publicly at events it calls Harvest Fest and Demo Night. Cameron’s thinking is simple. If you really know something, you can teach somebody else about it. According to him, that’s a big reason Bennett students retain and apply more than three-quarters of what they learn.
A Portfolio Says More Than a GPA
All that work doesn’t just disappear at the end of the year. Bennett keeps a digital portfolio of every student’s work, and as students get older, they help document it themselves.
Cameron said that portfolio has become increasingly important for college applications. When thousands of applicants share the same GPA and test scores, a portfolio shows what gives a student purpose and what they can actually do.
It Isn’t Easy, and That’s Okay
Cameron was upfront that this approach comes with real challenges. For one, no learning management system was built for competency-based grading, so Bennett set out to build its own, with plans to share it with other schools heading in the same direction.
Parents can also feel a little uneasy at first. Most of us grew up with desks in rows and letter grades, so a different model can feel unfamiliar, especially when families are paying tuition and want to know the outcomes are there.
The results were already starting to answer that. Back in 2022, Bennett students were outscoring national averages on the SAT and ACT by wide margins, and the school was getting ready to send its first graduating class off to college. When surveyed, Bennett students described school as engaging, exciting, and meaningful. Compare that to what most middle and high schoolers nationally say: tired, bored, and stressed.
Wrapping It Up
Grades aren’t going anywhere anytime soon, and they do give schools useful information. They don’t tell the whole story. Going beyond letter grades and measuring student mastery is really about asking what’s happening behind that letter, and whether students leave the classroom knowing what they can actually do.
Your school doesn’t have to copy Bennett’s model to take something from it. Start by asking your team a few questions. Do students know what they’ve mastered, or just what grade they got? Does your feedback tell them what to work on next? Are students showing what they know, or mostly recalling it?
Keep the Conversation Going
If this got you thinking, catch the full episode with Cameron on the School Success Podcast. And come hang out in the School Success Community, where school leaders swap ideas about what’s working in their schools.
At the end of the day, it all comes back to one question. What can our students actually do?
Latest Post
Is Your To-Do List Moving Your School Forward?
Sep 29, 2026
Beyond Letter Grades: Measuring Student Mastery
Sep 15, 2026
How Educator Language Shapes Student Confidence
Aug 26, 2026
Why Trust Matters in School Leadership
Aug 12, 2026
Sustainable School Growth Beyond Tuition
Jul 29, 2026
How Trauma-Informed Schools Improve Student Outcomes
Jul 15, 2026
Accreditation as a Growth Strategy for Schools
Jun 29, 2026
Why School Leaders Need Mentors
Jun 15, 2026
Clear School Value: The Key to Enrollment
May 29, 2026
How to Manage Growth Without Losing School Culture
May 15, 2026
™








